Hello, we are planning to order a new car in Dec., there is a choice: Mini Clubman S , Countryman S (without 4all) or a BMW X1(sDrive 2.0d) Now we are currently 2, maybe this will change over the next 2-4 years therefore a slightly more spacious car should come from, so far we have the normal Cooper S (are also satisfied with the car) now the question would be what do you think about it? Still our favorite : Clubman S (real Mini) unfortunately also doesn’t have really large luggage compartment like a Polo v ichlichicht. But offers a lot of driving fun ß unfortunately I find the entrance to the back over the clubdoor not so much, a real 4 doorr is better there already especially if you have to invite a child and fasten it. (Gives here good experiences in things Clubman with pram or baby shell, etc) (list price 34t€) X1 is of course a completely different car looks high quality (vs Countryman) at least from the cockpit is certainly also most expensive…(driving fun a la Mini is of course not comparable) Problem that there are no smart petrol engines with BMW (no X1 2.8 forks also sporty diesel is only available as xDrive… Luggage compartment and space is good (list price 45t€) Countryman is from the outside ok unfortunately the cockpit looks so cheap (KIA, Hyunday and Co) let greetings that we really don’t want it at all, of course I have to say from the driving feeling, he drives like a mini you notice very direct steering Sporty etc… clap and creak out of the Cockpit was already listening during the test drive… .. trunk and space is good (list price about 36t€) now I look forward to your comments …. : -)