Fiat 500 1.4 Black Jack or Toyota Aygo go&cool

Hello, am looking for a city flicker ( 15-20tKM per year 80% city 20% highway ) and have received the following deals. price 750€ Fiat 500 1.4L Handswitch Limited ” Black Jack ” Edition Limited to 3000 pieces NP 17,90€ 2x Hand 50000km BJ 2011 Black Matte Automatic Air Conditioning Xenon Partial Leather Inerscope Sound System PDC Standing Heating etc. price 7300€ Toyota Aygo 1.0 68PS BJ 2013 18,000km 1 Hand NP 13,500 Air Conditioning PDC Rearview Camera Cool&Go Package Which car would you recommend? Tend to the 500’s as it is FULLLY REFUNDED but I think with 101hp it will consume a lot especially in the city. Are there known flaws in the 500’s except the timing belts? Thanks for your tips / answers