Repainting by Parkrempler good or bad done?

Hello guys, I caused a dent when parking on the side due to carelessness. It was important to me that you see almost nothing at the end. An acquaintance agreed to repair the damage for 500€ (did not let it run through the insurance company). A first repair was already done because the first result was catastrophic. Now the paintr thought it would not work, because silver is very difficult to paint and another repair was not possible. I wanted to hear your opinion about it, especially those who know well whether it is true. See pictures. I find the craziest edge, which, so to speak, no longer exists. What do you think?