Which to Take: VW EOS or Golf Convertible

Hello EOS fans, I have a problem: friend would like to drive cabrio once and exchange your very well-kept Audi A3 Ambition 2 door for a convertible. I, who has no idea of convertibles, even BMW 3s drive, advised you to EOS or Golf. However, we can not decide between EOS and Golf. What do you think speaks for EOS or the galf convertible? I have already listed the following points, by the way, machine should become the 1.4 TSI with 122 or 160 hp. If driven against EOS yesterday too, however EOS 140 hp TDI against Golf 105 hp TDI…so I found the EOS quieter and less cuddly. But is probably mainly on the engine or? Ohso, car should also be fully driven in winter! So is no summer convertible. Tendency is currently going to golf, because cheaper and possibly easier to sell again. EOS-Ruf is probably quite damaged by water entrances. My friend also thinks EOS drive only older people… 😉 we want to buy an almost new, so day registration or demonstration car. Your opinions on this??? Thank you! Willi