I urgently need decision-making help VW vs MINI

Good morning, I am currently looking for a nice convertible. I have fallen in love with the design of the new Mini Cooper Roadster JCW. Now I am facing a difficult decision for me. To choose a Mini Cooper Roadster S for 31400€ (8,47%) discount. and a VW Golf 6 TSI 1.4 160 hp here is the final price at 28100 (13% discount). Reason clearly says that the VW is the better car because it offers significantly more comfort and above all “more car” for the money b ekomm. I find it very stylish from the design. The other side clearly says Mini because it is simply a fun car and unique from the design, because I really like the “retro look”. The price difference here is quite large compared to the comfort car to the fun car How would you decide? Unfortunately the JCW Cooper Roadster is very expensive otherwise this would be my absolute favorite because everything fits here in my opinion. What about discounts at the dealers? Mini dealers I have only got 5% discount and there is only one financing with 4.9 at VW currently 3.9%. My current driving behaviour: about 15000km annually with 50% city, 50%. On excursions on weekends it looks of course different. Have currently always been able to use the following vehicles: Porsche Boxter S, Golf 6 R. At the moment I have unfortunately no own vehicle, that should change however soon I thank you for your help and hope that the decision will soon be easier for me. .